Cardmarket vs TCGplayer: why the same card has two prices, and which one is yours

Collectors discover the gap the first time they compare an app that shows dollars with a website that shows euros and find the "same" card twenty, thirty, forty percent apart. The reflex is to assume one source is stale or lying. Usually neither is: they are measuring different things in different places.

Two marketplaces, two continents, two sets of buyers#

Cardmarket is the dominant marketplace for Pokémon, Magic and Yu-Gi-Oh! singles in Europe. Its sellers are mostly private collectors and small shops in Germany, France, Italy, Spain and the rest of the continent, listing in euros, and it lists cards in every European language alongside English and Japanese. TCGplayer, owned by eBay since 2022, is the dominant one in the United States: its sellers are mostly stores, it lists in dollars, and it is overwhelmingly an English-language market.

That geography does three things to prices. First, supply differs: a set that was heavily printed for the European market is cheap on Cardmarket and less so on TCGplayer, and the reverse happens for products distributed mainly in North America. Second, the buyers differ: a French collector pays a premium for a French card that an American buyer would not touch. Third, shipping and customs put a wall between the two: moving a €4 card across the Atlantic costs more than the card, so the markets never fully equalise. Arbitrage only closes the gap on expensive cards, where shipping is a rounding error, which is why the gap is usually narrowest on the priciest singles and widest on the cheap ones.

What each headline number actually measures#

The two sites do not compute their headline figures the same way, and this alone explains a good part of the gap. On a Cardmarket card page you see several numbers at once: a From price (the cheapest copy currently listed, in any condition the filter allows), a Price Trend (Cardmarket's own smoothed estimate, weighted towards recent sales), and averages of the sale prices over the last day, seven days and thirty days. On TCGplayer you see a Market Price, which the site derives from completed sales over a recent window, and the current listings with their lowest and median figures.

So a "Cardmarket price" and a "TCGplayer price" quoted side by side may be a cheapest-listing on one and a completed-sales figure on the other, in two currencies, on two continents. The surprise is not that they differ; it is that people expect them to match.

Currency: converting is estimating#

A card at €50 on Cardmarket and $55 on TCGplayer looks like a ten percent gap; at a different exchange rate it is a twenty percent gap or none. Any app that shows you one converted total for a collection is showing an estimate that moves with the currency market as much as with the card market. The honest way to display it is the way the sources do: euros for European figures, dollars for American ones, and the converted figure labelled as such. That is why Zukan draws every venue with its own currency and marks any converted quote as an estimate rather than summing them into one number.

Language: a printing is a market#

Cardmarket lets you filter a card by language, and the price ladder it reveals is instructive. English and Japanese usually sit at the top; German, French, Italian and Spanish below, sometimes far below; Portuguese and the smaller languages lower still. On TCGplayer most of those cards simply do not exist as separate listings. If your collection is in French, a valuation built on TCGplayer data is a valuation of a collection you do not own. It is one of the reasons the catalogue behind Zukan keeps each language as its own printing with its own price rather than folding them into "the card".

Which one is your price#

• You live in Europe and would sell on Cardmarket: use Price Trend for a valuation and the 7-day average to confirm it; use From to know what a buyer is comparing you against.
• You live in the United States: use TCGplayer Market Price, and check the lowest listing for what a buyer sees.
• You are buying, anywhere: the lowest listing on the marketplace you can actually order from, plus its shipping, is your price. A cheaper figure on the other continent is a curiosity.
• You are valuing a collection for yourself: pick one market and stay on it. A total built from whichever site is higher for each card is a fiction, and one built from the average of the two describes a market that does not exist.

Rejoins plus de 5 000 collectionneurs

Découvre ce que vaut
ta collection.

Every venue drawn as itself: Cardmarket in euros, TCGplayer in dollars, each with its own date.

• The card sheet shows a range with every venue behind it named, never one blended figure.
• Quotes in another currency are converted at the central bank rate and labelled as estimates, never summed with the rest.
• Prices are read nightly and every figure carries the moment it was read, so a three-week-old number cannot pass for a current one.

Télécharger dans l'App StoreDisponible surGoogle Play

Téléchargement gratuit · iPhone · Android

What about eBay, PriceCharting and CardTrader#

The two big marketplaces are not the whole market. eBay sold listings are the most direct record of what people paid, on both continents, and they include graded cards, which neither Cardmarket nor TCGplayer handles well. PriceCharting turns those sold listings into per-printing, per-grade figures in dollars, and is the reference for graded prices. CardTrader is a smaller European marketplace whose listings sometimes undercut Cardmarket. A serious valuation looks at more than one, which is why Zukan's card sheet lists several venues instead of picking a winner.